ISE25/20-21
Subject: | welfare services, social welfare and services |
Hong Kong
Japan
(a) | Accommodation: similar to Hong Kong's temporary accommodation places for the homeless, HSSCs are entrusted to relevant NGOs. Lodgers with work capability can stay for a maximum period of six months. At present, there are about 350 accommodation places in HSSCs. During their stay, they will be provided with integrated support including life counselling, health, psychological, housing and legal consultation to enhance lodgers' ability to become self-reliant. In 2021, the budget set aside for the operation of HSSCs amounted to ¥1,475 million (HK$104 million);21Legend symbol denoting See Kiener, J. and Mizuuchi, T. (2018), 東京都財務局(2020年), 東京都福祉保健局:《ホームレスの自立支援等に関する東京都実施計画(平成26年策定、第3次)に定める施策評価書》(2019年) and 東京都福祉保健局:《ホームレスの自立支援等に関する東京都実施計画(第4次)》(2019年).
|
(b) | Employment assistance: while HSSCs are operated by NGOs, staff from governmental employment service centres are assigned to HSSCs to provide vocational consultation and placement services to lodgers. Besides, HSSCs also cooperate closely with a publicly funded organization, namely Tokyo Council of Promotion of Employment Support Business for the Homeless (東京ホームレス就業支援事業推進協議会, "the Employment Council"). The Employment Council was formed in 2005, i.e. a few years after the promulgation of the Homeless Act, with a view to giving employment assistance to the homeless and those on the edge of homelessness due to unemployment or unstable jobs. It comprises members from the Tokyo Metropolitan Government, chambers of commerce, labour organizations, social welfare organizations and academic institutions.22Legend symbol denoting See Kiener, J. and Mizuuchi, T. (2018), 東京ジョブステーション(2020年 and 2021年), 東京都福祉保健局:《ホームレスの自立支援等に関する東京都実施計画(平成26年策定、第3次)に定める施策評価書》(2019年) and 東京都福祉保健局:《ホームレスの自立支援等に関する東京都実施計画(第4次)》(2019年).
Among other employment support such as provision of job information, the Employment Council holds seminars to give lodgers of HSSCs advice on job-seeking, guidance on preparation of résumés and training on interview skills. More specifically, lodgers of HSSCs can take part in the career experience programme organized by the Employment Council in cooperation with different companies in the private sector. Under the programme, participants will be given a chance to work in actual workplaces for a short period (usually within one month) with an incentive pay from the Employment Council. Likewise, employers will also be rewarded with a subsidy to cover the cost of providing opportunities for the homeless to gain working experience.23Legend symbol denoting The career experience programme is run in four prefectures which have relatively more homeless people (i.e. Aichi, Kanagawa, Osaka and Tokyo). Based on public domain information, the levels of incentive pay and subsidy in Tokyo appear not available. In the programme implemented in Osaka, participating employers will be rewarded with a maximum subsidy of ¥18,000 (HK$1,269) for programme up to 16 days and participants will receive an incentive pay of ¥3,000 (HK$212) per day. See 大阪ホームレス就業支援センター(2021年), 東京都福祉保健局:《ホームレスの自立支援等に関する東京都実施計画(平成26年策定、第3次)に定める施策評価書》(2019年) and 厚生労働省(2006年). Through joining the programme, it is expected that participants will become less anxious about employment with stronger motivation to work, while employers can hire suitable staff based on their performance;24Legend symbol denoting In sum, there were an annual average of 7 100 people getting a job with the help of the Employment Council during 2014-2017, representing its considerable effort into providing employment opportunities for those in need. See 東京都福祉保健局:《ホームレスの自立支援等に関する東京都実施計画(平成26年策定、第3次)に定める施策評価書》(2019年). and |
(c) | Aftercare services: to prevent recurrence of homelessness, aftercare services in the form of regular home visits, sharing sessions, vocational and legal consultation, etc. are provided to users within one year upon their departure from HSSCs.25Legend symbol denoting See 東京都福祉保健局:《ホームレスの自立支援等に関する東京都実施計画(平成26年策定、第3次)に定める施策評価書》(2019年) and 東京都福祉保健局:《ホームレスの自立支援等に関する東京都実施計画(第4次)》(2019年).4 |
Singapore
(a) | Engaging street sleepers: facilitated by MSF, the PEERS Network partners offer their support according to their strength, from befriending to mentoring. The Network has been joined by about 35 organizations or units since launch, and there is a PEERS Office under MSF to oversee the homeless services;35Legend symbol denoting See Parliament of Singapore (2021a) and The Pride (2020).
|
(b) | Offering sleeping shelters: some of the PEERS Network partners have been voluntarily offering their premises as Safe Sound Sleeping Places ("S3Ps") for homeless people to rest overnight. S3Ps are typically sited in premises of religious organizations (e.g. churches, mosques, temples), and can be in the form of a hostel room or informal bed space in a hall, basement, etc. They complement existing traditional shelters, making it easier for the government and NGOs to engage the homeless. These S3P providers generally allow the homeless people to stay in their premises until they have been referred to transitional shelters, secured long-term housing options, or their issues have been resolved. Though the government does not get involved in direct provision of facilities, MSF has given guidance on converting premises into S3Ps. There were about 700 S3P spaces as at May 2020.36Legend symbol denoting See Bless Community Services (2020 and 2021), Parliament of Singapore (2020a, 2020b, 2021a and 2021c) and The Online Citizen (2020). During the nationwide lockdown arising from the pandemic, S3Ps allowed the homeless to stay at the premises during day time as well;37Legend symbol denoting To curb COVID-19 infections, a nationwide lockdown was imposed between April and June 2020. The requirement that every individual must stay home during the lockdown, unless with specific reasons (e.g. working for essential service providers, get essential goods and services), caused S3Ps to expand the operating hours to let the homeless stay indoors for a whole day. See Gov.sg (2020) and Parliament of Singapore (2020b). and
|
(c) | Initial outcome: the Network, by pooling together the resources and expertise, appears to be quite effective. By end-2020, it has cumulatively engaged 1 200 homeless individuals over one and a half years through outreach walks or referrals. Among them, 12% already moved into public rental housing and 9% either returned home, moved into family members' homes or accommodation arranged by employers, while the rest were arranged with temporary shelters like S3Ps. Noting that some homeless people are not eligible for public rental housing (e.g. having family members who can house them or not meeting citizenship criterion), the Singapore government has pledged that the relevant authority will work with the PEERS Network partners to assess the circumstances of each case, and may exercise flexibility to grant them a tenancy if all other housing options for the individuals have been exhausted.38Legend symbol denoting See Parliament of Singapore (2021b). |
Concluding remarks
Prepared by Dickson CHUNG
Research Office
Information Services Division
Legislative Council Secretariat
26 August 2021
Hong Kong
| |
1. | Census and Statistics Department. (2021) Table 1A: Population by Sex and Age Group.
|
2. | GovHK. (2017) LCQ6: Support Services for Street Sleepers.
|
3. | GovHK. (2018) LCQ12: Policy on and Support for Homeless People.
|
4. | Hong Kong Council of Social Service. (2017) Submission on Policies on Street Sleepers and the Relevant Support Services and Actions/Measures. LC Paper No. CB(2)1093/16-17(02).
|
5. | I. CARE Programme, The Chinese University of Hong Kong and City-Youth Empowerment Project, Department of Applied Social Science, City University of Hong Kong. (2016) Homeless Outreach Population Estimation Hong Kong 2015: Research Report.
|
6. | Kornatowski, G. and Wong, H. (2018) Homeless in Hong Kong: The Evolution of Official Homeless Assistance and the Context of Housing.
|
7. | Labour and Welfare Bureau. (2018) Administration's Response to Welfare Support for the Homeless. LC Paper No. CB(2)1594/17-18(01).
|
8. | Legislative Council Secretariat. (2019) Statistical Highlights on Street Sleepers in Hong Kong. LC Paper No. ISSH17/18-19.
|
9. | Minutes of Joint Meeting of the Panel on Home Affairs and Panel on Welfare Services of the Legislative Council. (2013) 22 July. LC Paper No. CB(2)1760/12-13.
|
10. | Minutes of Joint Meeting of the Panel on Welfare Services and Panel on Food Safety and Environmental Hygiene of the Legislative Council. (2017) 27 March. LC Paper No. CB(2)2007/16-17.
|
11. | Minutes of Meeting of the Panel on Welfare Services of the Legislative Council. (2017) 13 February. LC Paper No. CB(2)1484/16-17.
|
12. | Minutes of Meeting of the Panel on Welfare Services of the Legislative Council. (2018) 9 April. LC Paper No. CB(2)1504/17-18.
|
13. | Minutes of Meeting of the Panel on Welfare Services of the Legislative Council. (2020) 11 May. LC Paper No. CB(2)1493/19-20.
|
14. | Social Welfare Department. (2015) Replies to Initial Written Questions raised by Finance Committee Members in Examining the Estimates of Expenditure 2015-16.
|
15. | Social Welfare Department. (2016a) Compassionate Rehousing and Alternative Housing Assistance.
|
16. | Social Welfare Department. (2016b) Replies to Initial Written Questions raised by Finance Committee Members in Examining the Estimates of Expenditure 2016-17.
|
17. | Social Welfare Department. (2017) Replies to Initial Written Questions raised by Finance Committee Members in Examining the Estimates of Expenditure 2017-18.
|
18. | Social Welfare Department. (2020a) Administration's Paper on Social Welfare Support Services for Street Sleepers. LC Paper No. CB(2)921/19-20(04).
|
19. | Social Welfare Department. (2020b) Replies to Initial Written Questions raised by Finance Committee Members in Examining the Estimates of Expenditure 2020-21.
|
20. | Social Welfare Department. (2021) Replies to Initial Written Questions raised by Finance Committee Members in Examining the Estimates of Expenditure 2021-22.
|
21. | 黃洪:《深水埗區露宿者研究報告》,2018年。
|
Japan
| |
22. | Kiener, J. (2014) Social Networks of Homeless People under the Influence of Homeless Self-Sufficiency Support Centres in Japan.
|
23. | Kiener, J. and Mizuuchi, T. (2018) Homelessness and Homeless Policies in the Context of the Residual Japanese Welfare State.
|
24. | Okamoto, Y. et al. (2004) Homelessness and Housing in Japan.
|
25. | TOKYOチャレンジネット:《介護職支援コース》,2021年。
|
26. | TOKYOチャレンジネット:《仕事・生活・住居・資金、お困りごとは》,2021年。
|
27. | 大阪ホームレス就業支援センター:《職場体験講習を利用してください》,2021年。
|
28. | 東京ジョブステーション:《組織のご案内》,2020年。
|
29. | 東京ジョブステーション:《事業の内容》,2021年。
|
30. | 東京都財務局:《令和3年度予算要求概要:福祉保健局》,2020年。
|
31. | 東京都教育委員会:《人権教育》,2021年。
|
32. | 東京都福祉保健局:《住居喪失不安定就労者等の実態に関する調査報告書》,2018年。
|
33. | 東京都福祉保健局:《ホームレスの自立支援等に関する東京都実施計画(平成26年策定、第3次)に定める施策評価書》,2019年。
|
34. | 東京都福祉保健局:《ホームレスの自立支援等に関する東京都実施計画(第4次)》,2019年。
|
35. | 東京都福祉保健局:《ホームレス対策の現状について》,2020年。
|
36. | 東京都総務局統計部:《平成12年(2000年)11月~平成17年(2005年)10月までの人口推計(補正)》,2006年。
|
37. | 東京都総務局統計部:《東京都の人口(推計)(補正)》,2021年。
|
38. | 厚生労働省:《現行ホームレス施策の概要等》,2006年。
|
39. | 厚生労働省:《ホームレスの実態に関する全国調査報告書》,2007年。
|
40. | 厚生労働省:《ホームレスの実態に関する全国調査(概数調査)結果》,2012年。
|
41. | 厚生労働省:《ホームレスの実態に関する全国調査(概数調査)結果》,2017年。
|
42. | 厚生労働省:《ホームレスの自立の支援等に関する特別措置法》,2017年。
|
43. | 厚生労働省:《ホームレスの実態に関する全国調査(概数調査)結果について》,2021年。
|
44. | 参議院:《ホームレスの自立の支援等に関する特別措置法の一部を改正する法律》,2012年。
|
45. | 衆議院:《ホームレスの自立の支援等に関する特別措置法の一部を改正する法律案の概要》,2017年。
|
46. | 総務省統計局:《年齢(5歳階級),男女別推計人口(平成15年2月確定値,平成15年6月概算値)》,2010年。
|
47. | 総務省統計局:《年齢(5歳階級)、男女別人口(2021年2月平成27年国勢調査を基準とする推計値、2021年7月概算値)》,2021年。
|
Singapore
| |
48. | Bless Community Services. (2020) S3P: A Bless Community Services Initiative Thanksgiving Report.
|
49. | Bless Community Services. (2021) S3P@YCKC.
|
50. | Gov.sg (2020) What You Can and Cannot Do during the Circuit Breaker Period. 11 April.
|
51. | Ministry of Social and Family Development. (2018) Welfare Homes.
|
52. | Ministry of Social and Family Development. (2019) MSFCares Issue 12.
|
53. | Ng, K.H. (2019) Homeless in Singapore: Results from a Nationwide Street Count.
|
54. | Parliament of Singapore. (2019) Number of Displaced Persons in Shelters.
|
55. | Parliament of Singapore. (2020a) Addressing Homelessness Problem as Reported in Study of over 1,000 People Sleeping in the Rough.
|
56. | Parliament of Singapore. (2020b) Assistance for Rough Sleepers and Measures to Help Them Cope with COVID-19 Circuit Breaker Conditions.
|
57. | Parliament of Singapore. (2021a) Committee of Supply - Head I (Ministry of Social and Family Development).
|
58. | Parliament of Singapore. (2021b) Numbers Helped under Partners Engaging and Empowering Rough Sleepers Network.
|
59. | Parliament of Singapore. (2021c) Support for Homeless People with Health Problems.
|
60. | Singapore Department of Statistics. (2021) M810001 - Indicators On Population, Annual.
|
61. | Singapore Statutes Online. (2020) Destitute Persons Act (Chapter 78).
|
62. | The Online Citizen. (2020) COVID-19: Shelters for the Homeless Hit Capacity as "Circuit Breaker" Measures Took Effect in S'pore. 13 April.
|
63. | The Pride. (2020) Tackling Homelessness during a Pandemic. 14 June.
|
64. | The Straits Times. (2019) Look back 2019: Landmark Study Highlights Issues of Homeless People. 18 December.
|
Others
| |
65. | Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. (2021a) HC3.1. Homeless Population.
|
66. | Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development. (2021b) HC3.2. National Strategies for Combating Homelessness.
|