Members' motions not intended to have legislative effect |
 | Year 2020 - 2021 |
| Year 2019 - 2020 |
| Year 2018 - 2019 |
| Year 2017 - 2018 |
| Year 2016 - 2017 |
| Members' motions not intended to have legislative effect (Year 2016 - 2017)
To view the wording of motions (and amendments to these motions), click the relevant links in the Subject column. To view the votes cast by individual Members, click the relevant links in the Voting Results column. |
-
* No debates on motions not intended to have legislative effect will be scheduled for such meetings.
| Council meeting | Subject | Motion | Moved by | Voting Results | Vote sequence |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 9.11.16 & 16.11.16 |
Abolishing the Mandatory Provident Fund offsetting mechanism
(Originally scheduled to be dealt with at the Council meeting of 19 October 2016) |
Original | Hon WONG Kwok-kin | Passed | 7 |
| Amendment to Original | Hon Jimmy NG | Negatived | 1 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Dr Hon CHIANG Lai-wan | Negatived | 2 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon Andrew WAN | Negatived | 3 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Dr Hon Fernando CHEUNG | Negatived | 4 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Dr Hon LAU Siu-lai | Negatived | 5 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon Michael TIEN | Negatived | 6 | ||
| Wording of the motion passed
Progress report | |||||
| 16.11.16 | Requiring the teaching of Chinese history as an independent subject at junior secondary level
(Originally scheduled to be dealt with at the Council meeting of 19 October 2016) |
Original | Hon CHEUNG Kwok-kwan | - | - |
| Amendment to Original | Hon IP Kin-yuen | Negatived | 1 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon Mrs Regina IP | Passed | 2 | ||
| Amendment to Original (Withdrawn) |
Dr Hon YIU Chung-yim | - | - | ||
| Amendment to Original (Withdrawn) |
Dr Hon KWOK Ka-ki | - | - | ||
| Original as amended | - | Passed | 3 | ||
| Wording of the motion passed
Progress report | |||||
| 16.11.16 | Urging the Government to amend the Fire Safety (Buildings) Ordinance
(Originally scheduled to be dealt with at the Council meeting of 26 October 2016) |
Original | Dr Hon Priscilla LEUNG | - | - |
| Amendment to Original | Hon CHAN Han-pan | Passed | 1 | ||
| Amendment to Original (Withdrawn) |
Dr Hon YIU Chung-yim | - | - | ||
| Original as amended | - | Passed | 2 | ||
| Wording of the motion passed
Progress report | |||||
| 23.11.16 | Vigorously promoting healthy market competition to counteract the market dominance of Link REIT
(Originally scheduled to be dealt with at the Council meeting of 26 October 2016) |
Original | Hon YUNG Hoi-yan | - | - |
| Amendment to Original | Hon SHIU Ka-fai | Negatived | 1 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon Andrew WAN | Passed | 2 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon Wilson OR | Negatived | 3 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Dr Hon Fernando CHEUNG | Negatived | 4 | ||
| Amendment to Original (Withdrawn) |
Dr Hon KWOK Ka-ki | - | - | ||
| Original as amended | - | Passed | 5 | ||
| Wording of the motion passed
Progress report | |||||
| 23.11.16 | Strengthening the role and functions of District Councils
(Originally scheduled to be dealt with at the Council meeting of 2 November 2016) |
Original | Hon LAU Kwok-fan | - | - |
| Amendment to Original | Dr Hon Fernando CHEUNG | Negatived | 1 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon WU Chi-wai | Passed | 2 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon HUI Chi-fung | Negatived | 3 | ||
| Original as amended | - | Passed | 4 | ||
| Wording of the motion passed
Progress report | |||||
| 30.11.16 | Formulating a comprehensive listing policy
(Originally scheduled to be dealt with at the Council meeting of 2 November 2016) |
Original | Hon Christopher CHEUNG | - | - |
| Amendment to Original | Hon James TO | Passed | 1 | ||
| Original as amended | - | Passed | 2 | ||
| Wording of the motion passed
Progress report | |||||
| 30.11.16 | Combating 'bogus refugees' | Original | Hon Holden CHOW | - | - |
| Amendment to Original | Hon HO Kai-ming | Passed | 1 | ||
| Amendment to Original (Withdrawn) |
Hon Claudia MO | - | - | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon YUNG Hoi-yan | Negatived | 2 | ||
| Amendment to Original (Withdrawn) |
Hon POON Siu-ping | - | - | ||
| Amendment to Original | Dr Hon Priscilla LEUNG | Negatived | 3 | ||
| Amendment to Original (Withdrawn) |
Dr Hon Fernando CHEUNG | - | - | ||
| Amendment to Original (Withdrawn) |
Hon James TO | - | - | ||
| Original as amended | - | Negatived | 4 | ||
| Motion negatived | |||||
| 7.12.16 | Formulating a housing policy to alleviate the keen housing demand | Original | Hon Paul TSE | Passed | 8 |
| Amendment to Original | Hon KWOK Wai-keung | Negatived | 1 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon LEUNG Yiu-chung | Negatived | 2 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon Wilson OR | Negatived | 3 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Dr Hon KWOK Ka-ki | Negatived | 4 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Dr Hon YIU Chung-yim | Negatived | 5 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon Andrew WAN | Negatived | 6 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Dr Hon Fernando CHEUNG | Negatived | 7 | ||
| Wording of the motion passed
Progress report | |||||
| 7.12.16 | Updating the Hong Kong Planning Standards and Guidelines and increasing community facilities to enhance living environment | Original | Hon CHAN Han-pan | - | - |
| Amendment to Original | Hon Alice MAK | Passed | 1 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Ir Dr Hon LO Wai-kwok | Passed | 2 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon Frankie YICK | Passed | 3 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon Tanya CHAN | Negatived | 4 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon Andrew WAN | Passed | 5 | ||
| Amendment to Original (Withdrawn) |
Hon LEUNG Yiu-chung | - | - | ||
| Amendment to Original (Withdrawn) |
Dr Hon YIU Chung-yim | - | - | ||
| Original as amended | - | Passed | 6 | ||
| Wording of the motion passed
Progress report | |||||
| 14.12.16 | Prerequisites for the next Secretary for Education | Original | Hon IP Kin-yuen | - | - |
| Amendment to Original | Hon CHEUNG Kwok-kwan | Passed | 1 | ||
| Amendment to Original (Withdrawn) |
Hon Charles Peter MOK | - | - | ||
| Amendment to Original (Not moved) |
Hon Nathan LAW (Not present) |
- | - | ||
| Original as amended | - | Passed | 2 | ||
| Wording of the motion passed
Progress report | |||||
| 14.12.16 | Formulating a territory-wide long-term bazaar policy | Original (Not moved) |
Dr Hon LAU Siu-lai (Not present) |
- | - |
| Amendment to Original | Hon SHIU Ka-fai | - | - | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon Steven HO | - | - | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon HUI Chi-fung | - | - | ||
| Motion was not moved | |||||
| 11.1.17 | Striving to make sign language an official language of Hong Kong | Original | Hon LEUNG Yiu-chung | Negatived | - |
| Motion negatived | |||||
| 11.1.17 | Expectations for the next Chief Executive | Original | Hon KWOK Wai-keung | Negatived | 8 |
| Amendment to Original | Hon Christopher CHEUNG | Negatived | 1 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon LAM Cheuk-ting | Negatived | 2 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon LEUNG Yiu-chung | Negatived | 3 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon Nathan LAW | Negatived | 4 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon IP Kin-yuen | Negatived | 5 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon Alvin YEUNG | Negatived | 6 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon Starry LEE | Negatived | 7 | ||
| Motion negatived | |||||
| 8.2.17 | Urging the Government to step up the regulation of money lenders and financial intermediaries | Original | Hon Alice MAK | - | - |
| Amendment to Original | Hon LEUNG Yiu-chung | Passed | 1 | ||
| Amendment to Original (Not moved) |
Hon WU Chi-wai (Not present) |
- | - | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon Kenneth LEUNG | Passed | 2 | ||
| Original as amended | - | Passed | 3 | ||
| Wording of the motion passed
Progress report | |||||
| 8.2.17 | Expeditiously conducting a comprehensive review of the Government's service outsourcing system | Original | Hon LUK Chung-hung | - | - |
| Amendment to Original | Hon Steven HO | Passed | 1 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon LEUNG Yiu-chung | Passed | 2 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon Charles Peter MOK | Passed | 3 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon POON Siu-ping | Negatived | 4 | ||
| Amendment to Original (Withdrawn) |
Dr Hon KWOK Ka-ki | - | - | ||
| Original as amended | - | Passed | 5 | ||
| Wording of the motion passed
Progress report | |||||
| 15.2.17 | Motion of Thanks | Original | Hon Starry LEE | Negatived | 4 |
| Amendment to Original | Hon WU Chi-wai | Negatived | 1 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Dr Hon Fernando CHEUNG | Negatived | 2 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon SHIU Ka-chun | Negatived | 3 | ||
| Motion negatived | |||||
| 1.3.17 | Actively studying the establishment of a middle class commission | Original | Hon Tommy CHEUNG | - | - |
| Amendment to Original | Hon Frankie YICK | Passed | 1 | ||
| Amendment to Original (Withdrawn) |
Ir Dr Hon LO Wai-kwok | - | - | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon HUI Chi-fung | Negatived | 2 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon KWOK Wai-keung | Passed | 3 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Dr Hon Elizabeth QUAT | Passed | 4 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon Michael TIEN | Negatived | 5 | ||
| Amendment to Original (Withdrawn) |
Dr Hon KWOK Ka-ki | - | - | ||
| Original as amended | - | Passed | 6 | ||
| Wording of the motion passed
Progress report | |||||
| 1.3.17 | Reviewing and reorganizing the Government structure | Original | Hon Kenneth LEUNG | Passed | 5 |
| Amendment to Original | Hon YIU Si-wing | Negatived | 1 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Dr Hon Helena WONG | Negatived | 2 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon CHAN Hak-kan | Negatived | 3 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Ir Dr Hon LO Wai-kwok | Negatived | 4 | ||
| Wording of the motion passed
Progress report | |||||
| 22.3.17 | Giving full play to the edges of local tourism resources | Original | Hon YIU Si-wing | Passed | 8 |
| Amendment to Original | Hon Mrs Regina IP | Negatived | 1 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon WU Chi-wai | Negatived | 2 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon Jeffrey LAM | Negatived | 3 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Dr Hon KWOK Ka-ki | Negatived | 4 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon Michael TIEN | Negatived | 5 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon Holden CHOW | Negatived | 6 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon LUK Chung-hung | Negatived | 7 | ||
| Wording of the motion passed
Progress report | |||||
| 22.3.17 | Ensuring the fair conduct of the Chief Executive Election | Original | Dr Hon YIU Chung-yim | Negatived | 6 |
| Amendment to Original | Hon Charles Peter MOK | Negatived | 1 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon Claudia MO | Negatived | 2 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon Paul TSE | Negatived | 3 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon Starry LEE | Negatived | 4 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon Alvin YEUNG | Negatived | 5 | ||
| Motion negatived | |||||
| 29.3.17 | Urgently improving public healthcare services in Kowloon East | Original | Hon Wilson OR | - | - |
| Amendment to Original | Hon HO Kai-ming | Passed | 1 | ||
| Amendment to Original (Withdrawn) |
Dr Hon Pierre CHAN | - | - | ||
| Amendment to Original | Dr Hon KWOK Ka-ki | Passed | 2 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon WU Chi-wai | Passed | 3 | ||
| Amendment to Original (Withdrawn) |
Hon SHIU Ka-chun | - | - | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon LEUNG Yiu-chung | Passed | 4 | ||
| Original as amended | - | Passed | 5 | ||
| Wording of the motion passed
Progress report | |||||
| 31.5.17 | Urging the next Chief Executive to reactivate constitutional reform
(Originally scheduled to be dealt with at the Council meeting of 29 March 2017) |
Original | Dr Hon KWOK Ka-ki | Negatived | 3 |
| Amendment to Original | Hon LEUNG Che-cheung | Negatived | 1 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Dr Hon Helena WONG | Negatived | 2 | ||
| Motion negatived | |||||
| 31.5.17 | Promoting 'Hong Kong people using Hong Kong water' and protecting local resources
(Originally scheduled to be dealt with at the Council meeting of 10 May 2017) |
Original | Hon Claudia MO | Negatived | 4 |
| Amendment to Original | Dr Hon Helena WONG | Negatived | 1 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon LAU Kwok-fan | Negatived | 2 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon Kenneth LEUNG | Negatived | 3 | ||
| Motion negatived | |||||
| 7.6.17 | Not forgetting the 4 June incident
(Originally scheduled to be dealt with at the Council meeting of 17 May 2017) |
Original | Dr Hon Helena WONG | Negatived | - |
| Motion negatived | |||||
| 7.6.17 | Combating bid-rigging to defend the rights and interests of property owners
(Originally scheduled to be dealt with at the Council meeting of 17 May 2017) |
Original | Hon LAM Cheuk-ting | - | - |
| Amendment to Original | Hon LAU Kwok-fan | Passed | 1 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon Alvin YEUNG | Passed | 2 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Dr Hon Fernando CHEUNG | Passed | 3 | ||
| Amendment to Original (Withdrawn) |
Hon KWOK Wai-keung | - | - | ||
| Original as amended | - | Passed | 4 | ||
| Wording of the motion passed
Progress report | |||||
| 14.6.17 | Formulating a bicycle-friendly policy and designating bicycles as a mode of transport
(Originally scheduled to be dealt with at the Council meeting of 24 May 2017) |
Original | Hon HUI Chi-fung | - | - |
| Amendment to Original | Hon LUK Chung-hung | Passed | 1 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon CHAN Han-pan | Passed | 2 | ||
| Amendment to Original (Withdrawn) |
Dr Hon YIU Chung-yim | - | - | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon Charles Peter MOK | Passed | 3 | ||
| Original as amended | - | Passed | 4 | ||
| Wording of the motion passed
Progress report | |||||
| 14.6.17 | Advocating the establishment of a 'baby fund'
(Originally scheduled to be dealt with at the Council meeting of 24 May 2017) |
Original | Dr Hon CHIANG Lai-wan | Negatived | 2 |
| Amendment to Original | Hon HO Kai-ming | Negatived | 1 | ||
| Amendment to Original (Not moved) |
Hon SHIU Ka-chun (Not present) |
- | - | ||
| Motion negatived | |||||
| 28.6.17 | Facing up to the aspirations of the people participating in the 1 July march
(Originally scheduled to be dealt with at the Council meeting of 21 June 2017) |
Original | Hon Andrew WAN | - | - |
| Amendment to Original (Not moved) |
Hon WONG Ting-kwong (Not present) |
- | - | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon Christopher CHEUNG | Passed | 1 | ||
| Original as amended | - | Passed | 2 | ||
| Wording of the motion passed
Progress report | |||||
| 28.6.17 | Safeguarding animal rights
(Originally scheduled to be dealt with at the Council meeting of 21 June 2017) |
Original | Hon KWONG Chun-yu | - | - |
| Amendment to Original | Hon Claudia MO | Negatived | 1 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Dr Hon Priscilla LEUNG | Passed | 2 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon Jeremy TAM | Passed | 3 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Dr Hon Elizabeth QUAT | Passed | 4 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon CHAN Hak-kan | Passed | 5 | ||
| Original as amended | - | Passed | 6 | ||
| Wording of the motion passed
Progress report | |||||
| 5.7.17 | Reforming outdated legislation and promoting the development of innovation and technology
(Originally scheduled to be dealt with at the Council meeting of 28 June 2017) |
Original | Hon Charles Peter MOK | - | - |
| Amendment to Original | Hon YUNG Hoi-yan | Passed | 1 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Ir Dr Hon LO Wai-kwok | Passed | 2 | ||
| Amendment to Original (Withdrawn) |
Hon Claudia MO | - | - | ||
| Amendment to Original | Dr Hon Elizabeth QUAT | Passed | 3 | ||
| Amendment to Original (Withdrawn) |
Hon YIU Si-wing | - | - | ||
| Amendment to Original (Withdrawn) |
Hon Alvin YEUNG | - | - | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon Kenneth LEUNG | Passed | 4 | ||
| Original as amended | - | Passed | 5 | ||
| Wording of the motion passed
Progress report | |||||
| 5.7.17 | Establishing a universal retirement protection system
(Originally scheduled to be dealt with at the Council meeting of 28 June 2017) |
Original | Hon LEUNG Kwok-hung | Negatived | 4 |
| Amendment to Original | Hon LEUNG Che-cheung | Negatived | 1 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon KWOK Wai-keung | Negatived | 2 | ||
| Amendment to Original | Hon Alvin YEUNG | Negatived | 3 | ||
| Motion negatived | |||||
| To be dealt with at the first regular Council meeting of the next session | Establishing a comprehensive 're-industrialization' policy regime
(Originally scheduled to be dealt with at the Council meeting of 5 July 2017) |
- | |||
| To be dealt with at the first regular Council meeting of the next session | Conducting a comprehensive review of labour legislation to improve labour rights and interests
(Originally scheduled to be dealt with at the Council meeting of 5 July 2017) |
- | |||
Share this page
